Skip to content

Check your vault

Checked against GM-Apprentice 1.12.98.

The skill behind this is campaign-qa. A campaign's notes drift: a fact changes in play and three other notes still say the old thing, a name gets reused, a link points nowhere. It reads the vault, finds those problems, shows you the evidence for each, and proposes a fix. Apart from a couple of mechanical clean-ups it reports afterwards, nothing changes until you say so.

  • After a big session or a big import.
  • At the end of a chapter.
  • Before you publish the campaign site, or when the site build warns about something.
  • When you have a nagging feeling that two notes disagree.

Starting phrases that work:

  • "Anything broken in the vault?"
  • "Check for contradictions in Chapter 2."
  • "Are any of my NPC names too close together?"
  • "Am I following the Three Clue Rule?"
  • "Check my notes for anything that shows wrong on the site."

On GM-Apprentice 1.12.98, using the Snowbound sample vault (clone or download tag sample-v2 to follow along), after the session in Wrap up a session. We typed the GM's side; the replies are the agent's own, trimmed ([...]) but not reworded.

You type

Anything broken in the vault?

The apprentice

The vault's version is current (1.12.98, matching the plugin), so I can run an audit. Which scope do you want?

  1. Full vault: every check, from canon and timeline through graph health, site faults, settings, world consistency and open spoilers, in one report grouped by severity.
  2. Current chapter: the same checks, limited to the chapter you're playing now.
  3. Specific files or one check: for example, only timeline validation, only the site faults, or a few NPC notes.

[...]

You type

Full vault.

The apprentice

I've run every check for the full audit. Nothing is critical, and the Session 5 canon holds together: the timeline, deaths, cure and early descent all match. The problems are notes that weren't updated after the move to Chapter 2, plus some housekeeping.

Warnings

W1. Kael still "knows" Tam is in the ice cave. In [[Kael Stonehand]], under Current Status → Knows (exclusive), it says "Tam lies dead in the ice cave at the foot of the crypt chute, in his shirt." Tam was carried up in Session 4 and buried in his coat in Session 5 ([[The Burying of Tam Rowe]]). Fix: change it to: "Tam is buried on the slope behind the Mule-Yard, in his coat."

W2. The Campaign Overview is still at the end of Chapter 1. In [[Campaign Overview]], Current Arc says the dragon "has woken and named its price", but it's dead. Key Factions says the order is "led by [[Abbot Severin]]", who is dead; the order chose [[Sister Wren]]. Fix: rewrite Current Arc for Harrowford in spring and Edda's request, and make Wren the order's leader.

[...]

W7. Seven items have a holder, but the holder's note doesn't list the item. [...]

  • [[The Ice Shards]] → Grenna. The shards were used up curing Hesta, so this holder is probably out of date.

[...]

Info

[...]

  • I4. The name Mattias Pell is close to [[Brother Matthias]]. You already chose to keep it at wrap-up. Fix: add a QA-DISMISSED marker so it isn't flagged again.

[...]

Everything else passed: timeline order, links, tones, tables, settings, D&D sheets (all six), wrap-up structure, NPC/PC pairs, open spoilers and world consistency. [...]

How do you want to handle these? You can approve all the proposed fixes, go through them in batches (W1–W3, W4–W7, then the Info items), or decide each one yourself with fix, skip or dismiss. Nothing has been changed yet. [...]

You type

Approve all the proposed fixes. The lamp is located_at, and promote the three planning drafts.

The apprentice

I've made all the fixes. Afterwards the index, relationship and NPC-stats checks came back clean and there are no broken links.

Fixed:

  • Kael's note: his knowledge now says Tam is buried behind the Mule-Yard in his coat, not lying in the ice cave.
  • Campaign Overview: Current Arc now covers Harrowford in spring and Edda's request. The order is now led by Sister Wren instead of the dead abbot.
  • Chapter 2 note: the template placeholders are replaced with a summary, a player Teaser and GM Notes. I wrote these from the Session 5 Wrap-Up, so read the Teaser before you publish, since players will see it.

[...]

The report is in _QA/QA_full_audit_2026-11-20.md (15 findings: 7 warnings, 8 info; 10 fixed, 2 dismissed). [...]

  • Canon: notes that contradict each other, or still say something that play has since changed.
  • Timeline: events in an impossible order, the dead turning up alive.
  • Names: NPCs or places close enough to confuse your players.
  • Clues: whether each conclusion the players must reach has at least three ways in (the Three Clue Rule), and clues that lead nowhere.
  • Graph health: broken links, orphaned notes, stubs left unfilled, relationships written in the wrong shape or stored twice.
  • Site faults, for a campaign with a site: names players can see that have no page, and hidden text at risk of showing.
  • Tones: relationship tones tidied to the standard words the site understands.
  • It asks how far to look first. The whole vault, the current chapter, or a few files.
  • Evidence, then a fix. Each finding names the note and the line, says why it matters, and proposes the change.
  • You decide each one: fix, skip or dismiss. Approve them all at once if you like.
  • Dismissing is remembered. It marks the note, and doesn't raise the same thing again unless something has changed since.
  • A report is saved to _QA/ in your vault.
  • Drafts get some slack. It knows a DRAFT note is expected to have gaps.
  • "Check my timeline for impossible sequences."
  • "Which NPCs have no relationships?"
  • "Tidy the tones in my campaign."
  • "Players can see Baron Vesper's name but he has no page."

With the vault clean, prep the next session, or publish your site with the problems it found fixed.